Planning ahead (I need suggestions and cats)

One of my newest characters, Amberkit, has a lot of potential for a complex plot. I actually have about three different ways it could go.

here is her cat creation!

Amberpaw goes to her first gathering. Shes very excited because she wants to meet the other clans. She talks to everyone she can and forms a friendship with one apprentice. After several days she misses them and sneaks out of her camp in the middle of the night. The apprentice is woke up by Amberpaw hiding in the shadows and reeking of stale prey. She explains that she missed them and left their territory to see them. They go to fourtrees and talk and play before going back to their clans. Around here is where the plots split into the three options.

A- Amberpaw starts telling them about her opinions on starclan, the warrior code, and the concept of clans, about how stupid she thinks it all is. The other cat is shocked, how could someone show so much disrespect for their own ancestors! They convince themselves its ok and it doesn't matter as long as they stay together. Amberpaw (or possibly Ambergaze by now) starts suggesting they should run away together. After turning her down several times it seems more like a threat then a offer. The cat can't take it anymore and tells the entire story during a gathering because they don't feel safe around Amber anymore.
cats that would be needed for this plot: Other apprentice(could be any gender)

B- They agree with everything she says. What dumb cat would believe in some dead dudes in the sky sending them 'prophecies'? They start to secretly spread this message through their clans and rally a group of cats who start meeting at fourtrees together in the middle of the night. They could either be found or form a group of rogues and wreck havoc for a bit.
Cats needed for this plot: Other apprentice, at least 3-5 cats who agree with them.(any gender)

C- After hearing about her beliefs they are disgusted and stop meeting with her. She starts threatening them but they just brush it off. Ambergaze pretends to have changed her views and they start meeting again, but when she gets pregnant it goes back to threats. When the kits are born she refuses to tell her clan who the father is. Ambergaze starts trying to guilt trip her mate but is surprised to see he wants nothing to do with her and has found another mate. Out of rage she stalks this mate for a while and eventually ends her life. Either a MC would find out about it or someone would have accidentally saw her do it. The clans would find out and she would be exiled or leave on her own terms and the kits would have to deal with the distrust from the clan.
Cats needs for this plot: Her mate(has to be a Tom), The kits, Murder victim, and possibly a witness.

which one of these seems like the best one? also, if you are interested in roleplaying one of the cats needed tell me and keep a watch on this. Keep in mind the plot you want may not get chosen..

Newtpaw would be perfect for option B! He knows that StarClan is real but thinks they are unreliable and the warrior code should be broken for good intentions. He's not one to fully buy onto everything and would find meeting others clans and loners fantastic as he could learn things ThunderClan doesn't teach.

Swiftpaw would be good for option A, because he believes in StarClan, and would eventually be scared of Amber, but would continue to be her friend in the beginning. Swift would eventually tell everyone because he isn't able to take it anymore.

I know Jughead already posted and all, just putting another option out there for you!

Numero C or A I like, and Spotpaw could be the other apprentice for A or a witness for C but I'm afraid he wouldn't be able to take part in B.