Who is your least favorite character?

I know a lot of strong feelings about this, so why just let them out in an organized fashion? Remember to not get offended by anyone's opinion on a character, it's just a book series even if it is my life. Here's an organizer:

List from worst third worst:
1.
2.
3.
Explanation of why:

Ex.
List from worst third worst:
1. Dovewing
2. Lionblaze
3. Spottedleaf
Explanation of why: Dovewing just makes me angry. She had an exaggerated relationship with her sister that she just puts up in flames at every opportunity. I know she thought everyone could hear and see like her at first, but Ivypaw obviously got upset whenever she talked about it. And her reaction to finding out Ivypool had been training in the dark forest makes me want to kill her. Also, Tigerheart and Bumblestripe. I hate pairing her with either of those cats, so she just should follow her sister and not have a mate. Her powers are made to be such a big deal, though she literally does nothing useful with them.
What I don't like about Lionblaze is the he is so OP, for no reason at all. He is so much like Dovewing in many ways. He is close to his sister, then he doesn't care that much when she dies. He has a Heathertail and Cinderheart, neither of which are good matches for him. He has an amazing power, and literally does nothing with it. The only cat from that prophecy that is good is Jayfeather, and he's a pimb.
I don't know why Firestar likes her so much. He was 10 moons old when she died, and she was full grown and a lot older than him by then. And apparently (though I haven't read Spottedleaf's Heart yet) she had some sort of romance with Thistleclaw when she was an apprentice. No thank you. Also, she is a stalker of cats in their dreams. She also tells very little information to cats when she knows a lot more helpful information.

I'm not sure if this counts as reviving a topic since this isn't the main rp board?

List from worst third worst:
1.Squirrelflight
2.Bramblestar
3.Thistleclaw
Honourable Mention: Hollyleaf
Explanation of why:

I'm gonna be brutally honest here. Squirrelflight did not deserve her warrior name when she got it. Sure, she went on the quest, but only after blackmailing, manipulating and pouting up a storm when she didn't get her way. Did she help? Sure, but ultimately, it felt like she was being rewarded for being so jealous that she didn't get a prophecy that she just had to push her way into Brambleclaw's. Starclan forbid the daughter of Firestar not get her own special prophecy. Now, to her credit, she has earned some of my respect... but only recently. Prior to the middle of Power of Three, I still referred to her as Squirrelpaw.

Bramblestar is just... he's trying too hard. While I get where the tom is coming from, he's not Firestar, and he will never be. I feel like the sooner he can learn to cope and embrace that, the better leader we'll see of him.

Thistleclaw ... Spottedleaf's Heart. That's really all that needs to be said.

Hollyleaf screams missed potential to me. I don't really dislike her, it's just... why Erins. Why?

Pika's hate list:

1. Crowfeather
   
2. Leafpool
   
3. Ashfur
   

I hate them all equally.

Crowfeather is a piece of s***. He's an emotional abusive father and mate. He ruined his son and mate's lives. He should have never taken a mate after Leafpool, his decision to basically bang Nightwhatever just to "prove his loyalty" is scummy. He dragged her along on his stupid ass angst train and created poor Breezesad who got a nightmare of a childhood thanks to him. Local deadbeat dad deserves to be exiled or worse.

And his handling of the discovery of his TC kits and comparison of Breeze to Lion! I don't care about his sad emo feelings because he didn't get the dream life he imagined. He's an emotionally incompetent moron.

Also I never got the whole falling in love with medicine cats biz. He freaking knew Leaf was an MCA, don't fall for MCA's. Love isn't some magical emotion that pops up outta nowhere and blindsides you. You gotta nurture that shizz. The hell was he thinking confessing his love to Leaf? Code-breaking, home-wrecking, life-wrecking scum.

Okay, I lied. I hate Crow more than all the cats.


Next on the list. Leafpool. She's a flip flop b****. Couldn't even face the consequences of her own actions so she decided to ruin literally everyone's lives. Squirrel/Bramble/Crow/Cinder/Lion/Holly/Jay/etc. Everyone got messed up because she was an indecisive idiot. Didn't even take her vows seriously. I mean, in this universe, cats don't have heats. They have consensual bang times, and those are presumably only to make kits since they don't really lust after each other in the books. Therefore, Leaf deliberately banged Crow to have babies on their little escape fest. Or Erin's just didn't think this through and I'm over thinking this. But if we follow cat physiology, cat matings will pretty much 100% result in kits. Either way, she should have known she was gonna have babs unless Cinderpelt was teaching abstinence only education.

I'm 100% sure I'm over thinking this. But I can't forgive her for messing up everyone's lives for her own selfish inability to face the consequences of her own actions. She is easily one of the most selfish cats in the books.

Ashfur is just a gross neckbeard. I'm only mad he ended up in StarClan "because his love was pure or something". He was a jealous binch and deserved to rot in the dark forest. I don't care if squirrelflight had 10 litters with him before breaking up with him. You don't set your whole camp on fire and try kill everyone because you didn't get the pussy. I can't believe Erin's justified his psycho abusive ways.

Saying that the rhetoric of "If I can't have her, no one can" is okay because he loved her is beyond problematic and straight up criminal minds level of crazy. It's never okay to kill someone or their kids. And it just adds this level of gross sexism to the series that I didn't need.

Sure, I'll join!

1. Breezepelt
2. Darkstripe
3. Hollyleaf
Explanation of why: Breezepelt because he's just unbearable! He's so apathetic and cruel and unfair, he has no respect for the warrior code, and he was willing to kill a blind medicine cat and a pregnant she-cat at a sacred StarClan meeting ground for medicine cats!
Darkstripe because he's such a coward. He was a horrible code-breaking cat right from the start, and the only reason why he didn't leave with Tigerclaw when he was exiled was due to fear of exile himself. Not to mention he acted like such a scaredy-cat when he realized he was sent to the Dark Forest. Like, what the heck, dude? Grow a pair, you know what you did!
And finally, Hollyleaf because she's pretty bland. I mean, sure, she's got quite a bit of stuff going on in her life after finding out she was a living example of a broken warrior code after dedicating her life to it, but who kills another cat to keep them quiet, just to tell every Clan what he threatened to tell them in the first place, then runs off and leaves her two poor brothers to deal with her consequences? That's kind of a d**k move there, Hollyleaf.

List from worst third worst:
1. Berrynose
2. Crowfeather
3. Squirrelflight x Brambleclaw (does this count?)
Explanation of why:

1. Berrynose just makes me mad. He thinks that because he doesn't have a tail that he's disabled and needs to be treated with respect. So what your tail is a little stub? Then that's one less thing you need to worry about when hunting! When he was talking to Lionpaw like a deputy when he was barely a new warrior, that just made me really angry. To top it off, his mate dies, then he just goes after her sister? He always talks down to his clanmates and is so arrogant and... ugg... I hate Berrynose...

2. As for Crowfeather, basically the rant Pikachu made.

3. Okay, time to talk incest.

Sandstorm is Brindleface's kit, and so is Ashfur, but we aren't talking about him. Anyways Brindleface's mate is Redtail.

Tigerstar is Leopardfoot's and Pinestar's kit. Leopardfoot and Redtail are siblings. See what I mean?

If not, here's a tree
_____________________________________
|Pinestar x Leopardfoot---Redtail x Brindleface|
|~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~|
|~~Sandstorm~~~~~~~~Tigerstar~~~~~~|
|~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~|
|~SquirrelflightXXXXXXXXXBrambleclaw~~~~|
-----------------------------------------------------
Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw are cousins... I know that "the son of the antagonist" and "the daughter of the protagonist" being together seems cool but... cmon...

List from worst to second worst:

1.Jaydie
2. MIllie more like GO AWAY ayye

Explanation of why:

Jay
Where to start?
He's so annoying with all that whining groaning moaning bullcrap. He's literally a puddle of stupid angst and pure salt. Why is he so angry all the time? A poorly written character- I honestly don't think anyone would be constantly pissed unless they had an actual reason.

Mille needs to just
assess her mother skills
I mean, I'm kinda taking this personally because I don't really like Millie and Graystripe together, but i mean, whatever makes em' happy.
However, Millie showed a LOT of favoritism after Briarlight got hurt. I mean, it's natural for a mother, after having a child have a near-death experience, to be a little bit more protective, but I honestly think she could've done a better job caring for her other children.
Another thing to add on to this is when Millie frickin scowled at Blossomfall when she got lost in the tunnels. I mean, she literally said that Briarlight would've done a better job???

Pika wrote:

Ashfur is just a gross neckbeard. I'm only mad he ended up in StarClan "because his love was pure or something". He was a jealous binch and deserved to rot in the dark forest. I don't care if squirrelflight had 10 litters with him before breaking up with him. You don't set your whole camp on fire and try kill everyone because you didn't get the pussy. I can't believe Erin's justified his psycho abusive ways.

I'm here for the neckbeard comment and to retweet this

I'm too lazy to do this for legit, but I hate Ashfur too for everything he was

Also, I really didn't like Bluestar. Her entire childhood was her constantly getting too angsty to do things until someone yelled at her. She betrayed her clan because she was total idiot and banged a Riverclan cat just because he was cute. And then she just abandoned her kits to Riverclan with the excuse it would save the clan. But, like it fugged up her kits and just made problems and eventually turned her into a sad old ghost. When she went crazy and abandoned Starclan I constantly wanted to punch her in the face.

oh yes it's time for harlem to rant about dovewing


who's on harlem's chopping block
1. dovewing
2. ashfur
3. daisy
honorable mentions: firestar, berrynose

dovewing
i never talk in all caps, well i mean... i've done it before, but i rarely do it. so, you're about to see something that you'll never see again from harlem.
I. HATE. DOVEWING.
I hate her with all my heart, soul, and mind. a lot of people say that Dovewing is a mary-sue, but I totally disagree. why? Dovewing is far too selfish and annoying to be a mary-sue. the only good thing she did was assist the clans once the lake dried up. While she only gained her powers when she was an apprentice, Lionblaze and Jayfeather did, too! they managed to adapt to their powers, but Dovewing just... didn't. Bumblestripe doesn't deserve her, he deserves all the love in the world, I love my son. oh, and don't even get me started on her and Ivypool. Dovewing got extremely mad at her sister for training in the dark forest, but Ivypool was just Ivypaw then, and she didn't know any better! she was taught to think that the dark forest was going to help her be the best warrior she could be so that she could protect her clan. plus, Dovewing wasn't all perfect, so I don't get why she yelled at her sister. she was meeting Tigerheart secretly, so if anything, Ivypool deserves to yell her heart out at Dovewing. Let's not forget that time where Dovewing told Tigerheart about Jayfeather's herbs, then she goes around and yells at Tigerheart for stealing them. It was her fault for telling him in the first place, honestly! While her sister is off having dreams where she could get killed, and her Clan (as well as all the others) are going through their own trials and troubles, all Dovewing can do is complain about her place in the prophecy and her powers. She's practically toying around with Bumblestripe's emotions and feelings. It makes me mad that a bunch of cats that I actually like are in some sort of relationship with her. They don't deserve Dovewing. If anything, Ivypool should've been the third cat in the prophecy. Ivypool was a far better sister, and a far better Clanmate than Dovewing will ever be. When the other cats in the prophecy lost their powers, they got right back to working like normal cats. What did Dovewing do? Surprise, surprise. She complained, and moped, and whined; like she always does! Every time she gets mad and sad, it's either for absolutely no reason, or a really stupid and pointless reason. So, yeah, excuse the rant, but Dovewing will always be the cat that I despise the most out of every other cat in the series. That includes the ones that are explicitly evil. Ever notice how most of the "good" cats in the series that we should like are usually hated, like Dovewing?

ashfur
I really, really hate when people ask me how I could bring myself to hate Ashfur. Maybe it has to do with the reason that he tried to kill Squirrelflight and her kits, and still got sent to StarClan. He wasn't even Squirrelflight's mate, but he got salty and jealous when she got together with Bramblestar. Also, keep in mind that Ashfur was already a full-grown warrior when Squirrelflight was just a kit. Ashfur seems way too controlling, not to mention that he's practically a yandere. A yandere starts out as harmless and innocent until their devotion towards the person they love becomes harmful and violent. That description is pretty much Ashfur's entire character development circle in a nutshell. This was already mentioned at the beginning of the paragraph, but it still makes me upset that Ashfur got a spot in StarClan. He doesn't deserve it. If I got to control who went to StarClan or not, Ashfur would be down in the Dark Forest quicker than the prophecy cats lost their powers. I'd even let Dovewing into StarClan, because at least she didn't attempt to murder a group of cats. That's what the Dark Forest is for. If murderers like Tigerstar (I love my son) can go to the Dark Forest, then Ashfur can, too. Imagine if the murder attempt had succeeded, and Squirrelflight and her kits had died. Would Ashfur have been sent to the Dark Forest? I have not a doubt in my mind that the answer is yes. I really liked Ashfur up until the whole deal with Ashfur x Squirrelflight began, and I honestly didn't see the huge personality twist coming.

daisy
While I do believe in second chances, Daisy is literally a seventeenth chance. There were many attempts to train Daisy to hunt and fight, but she didn't succeed in any of them. So, she pretty much became a permanent queen. While she did provide a lot of kits for the Clan, Daisy is just plain annoying to me. She seemed to get a bit bossy with the other queens after she settled into ThunderClan life. At least those queens can actually fight and hunt. It seems to me like Daisy only cares about her kits. She stays in ThunderClan so that she and her kits can be protected and well-fed, which is awfully selfish. She doesn't even contribute anything! More kits mean more mouths to feed, which means more work for the warriors and apprentices. Most of the time, after a queen's kits enter apprenticehood, they become a warrior again and actually help the Clan catch food. Daisy doesn't. Don't get me wrong, I think that Daisy is a decent mother. Well, she's better than most (cough, cough, Millie). Let's not also forget the fact that Daisy wouldn't even change her name into a legitimate Clan name. She's literally a stray cat living in the ThunderClan nursery, which I find to be stupid.

honorable mentions:
firestar
He's just a plain Gary Stu. He's always talking about teamwork and peace, but sometimes that can't work, especially not in the world of Warriors. Plus, I got bored of him after the first series. So... yeah.

berrynose
"Honeyfern, you're the love of my life, you're everything to me, I love you so mu- oh, crap, you're dead! Hey, Poppysong, Honeyfern's sister, let me hook up with you!"


oh my gosh, that was fun

Squirrelnose wrote:

He(Lionblaze) is close to his sister(Dovewing), then he doesn't care that much when she dies.

Dovewing DIED?!  Spoiler Alert!

Thank you somebody for hating Dovewing as much as I do. She could be the amazing fighter and hunter that everyone treats her like, but instead decides to mope in complain and get into pointless relationships. I honestly find that her (as well as Spottedleaf and Leafpool), kind make the books a little sexist with their damsel in distress role, while they could have been saving everyone's butts. Dove wing is just plain stupid and a jerk, to basically everybody, especially her sister, who she claims to be extremely close to. And her whole Tigerheart relationship makes literally no sense for many reasons. Bumblestripe doesn't deserve her, and she think it is acceptable to use him. It is not.

@Mamenchisaurus, Dovewing isn't Lionblaze's sister. I was talking about Hollyleaf.

No, she doesn't die

She isn't even his sister

Also, I heard a power of three fan thing that Hollyleaf has the power to manipulate, kinda like Sol, but she can only convince them to follow orders, Sol can tell them anything like StarClan is useless, or that he can predict things StarClan can't. Her and Jayfeather try to control Lionblaze, but he remains neutral. Hollyleaf becomes deputy/leader and Jayfeather becomes head medicine cat. ThunderClan gets weakened from the inside because the two most important positions in a clan make horrible decisions plainly because they believed it was right for the clan. ShadowClan is still being brainwashed by Sol, and the two clans become one. Hollyleaf and Sol become the two voices of righteousness. Though the clan becomes shattered as the two "leaders" attempt to become higher in authority and the clan divides and takes sides. Lionblaze goes to WindClan and RiverClan and tries to get them to fight Thunder/ShadowClan, only RiverClan agrees because Onestar is being Onestar. At the battle, Thunder/ShadowClan is defeated due to their broken allegiances. Both Hollyleaf and Sol are killed, and everyone gets snapped out of their brainwash.

I think the ending is similar to how Tigerstar died, because he thought he could control BloodClan. Hollyleaf and Sol both died because they tried to control one another and it broke the clan. Also, I liked the original series ending, it was nice.

1. Clear Sky
2. Dovewing
3. Bluestar
Explanation of why:
Clear Sky
1. Got mad and told Gray Wing he wasn't a brother to him anymore because Gray Wing killed one of Clear Sky's cats out of self-defense.
2. After Gray Wing saved Storm's only surviving kit and brought it to Clear Sky out of courtesy, Clear Sky rejects the poor kit and refuses to take it, even though it would be his only memorial of Storm.
3. After Gray Wing raised the kit, Thunder, Clear Sky comes and takes him back, because whoops, Clear Sky wants him back now!
4. Was greedy for power and territory, which resulted in a Great Battle, leading to many of his own tribemates' deaths.
5. Exiled Jagged Peak because of a wound he never even bothered to help fix. "Recover, or leave the group. Everyone must take part."
6. Killed Misty because she refused to leave territory that Clear Sky didn't even own
7. Killed a cat that helped his own mother raise him. Clear Sky never even feels the slightest bit of regret for this until his mother comes and visits him.
8. Begged for the other groups' help when he never helped them
9. Mistreated Falling Feather when she didn't show the loyalty Clear Sky expected of her
10. Starved Jackdaw's Cry, even after claiming to feed him and take care of him. Later on, Clear Sky attacks Gray Wing's group because Jackdaw's Cry hunted for himself, which would've never happened if YOU didn't starve him for 2 days.
While Clear Sky DOES improve after the 3rd book of DOTC, he still decently often shows signs of his "old self."

I'd say probably Firestar for reasons mentioned before.

List from worst third worst:
1.dovewing
2.ashfur
3.breezepelt
Explanation of why:
dove wing: I just disliked here since book one of omen of the stars, she feels like a marry sue to me. also irritating that here powers are only used for plot reasons
ashfur: oh oh poor ashfur gets rejected by his love and you know what he did he tried to kil here father her mate and tried to burn here kits alive. thats just really needed don’t you think?
breezepelt: real struggle between choosing him or his father bud you know what I figured I just hate breeze pelt more. He always “strives to get the attention from his father” witch is immediately a good excuse for al his stupid actions