Even Starclan Makes Mistakes[UNAPPROVED]

Minkpaw is a shy she-cat. She hates fighting and this little angel is sent to tears by just a simple fail. On her Moonstone journey, she meets Finpaw, a clumsy and skittish Starclan tom, formerly from Shadowclan. They get along well and he begins to visit her dreams regularly. He's grown quite attached and helps her train/gain confidence/gives her therapy during these meetings- however, he does not have the consent of the rest of Starclan.
The two become good friends. Minkpaw improves on all fields and nobody knows why(other than Fin and Mink). This leads to a few different things.
1) Minkpaw grows somewhat reckless without realizing it, putting her in several near-death situations- all of which she survives. This makes her faith in Starclan/Finpaw grow.
2) She tells a close friend and they find out. They try to convince her that this is not good and takes it up with Nettlesting or Silentpaw/Watermint. They give her a lecture about this.
Meanwhile, Finpaw gets in trouble with Starclan for visiting this one single cat and is punished. Maybe if they think it is serious enough, they will send him into the Dark Forest(StC can go in there, you know), perhaps he is no longer to appear in dreams or moonstones, or maybe they simply ostracize him(or anything else the starclan people seem fit)

CAT ROLES
Starclan Punishment Deciders:
Minkpaw's Friend:

no the kit thing is not happening omg

like
jesus-starclan babies?

Before anyone signs up, this plot is not approved.

I mean yeah, it's not approved, and the kit thing was just a joke...
Unless you mean that it can't and won't be approved?

StarClan speaking to living cats besides leaders and medicine cats outside of Moonstone Journeys is currently not aloud, sorry about that :/

But that's why he gets in trouble after about 2 irl months or less.

I'm talking about out of character rules, not in character.  While I think this could be an interesting plot, staff has chosen to limit the ability to speak to StarClan and Dark Forest cats casually for the sake of not being overwhelmed by plots of that sort, AND to leave that kind of stuff for special site-wide plots.  I'm sorry for the disappointment Jade, but no.

Ah, ok, I see. Makes sense. Worth a try though!