Sagestar

Who's notable achievements is that he was one of the original the Leaders of Shadowclan. He fought against a rogue threat, and in the end was murdered by Reedstar.

vs


Deernose

Who's notable achievements are that he was one of the oldest cats in Windclan (besides Falconstar). Was part of a prophecy at one point. Somehow never had children in his whole two years on WCC. One of the only cats to invoke the wrath of Eaglethorn and not die because of it. Had a small plot specifically for him. Went insane, tried to kill Brindlesong and probably had a relationship with her daughter (who was also Eaglethorn's). Also outlived most other cats in the forest.