Specklefur

Who's notable achievements is that she was candidate to become deputy, turned the ties of the Riverclan vs Thunderclan battle at their camp while winning Sunningrocks over, saved a Windclan medicine cat apprentice, broke most of her paws when falling out of a tree to save a younger apprentice.(She was an apprentice at this time as well) Has been undoubtedly loyal for many seasons. Saved a Thunderclan kit from a fox. Has fought in countless battles, mostly with Shadowclan and Riverclan. Has completed mentoring many apprentices.

vs


Dewstar

Who's notable achievements are that she participated in the battle against the Deomilites, close friends with the original SkyClan, took on leadership duties while still the deputy because Mossstar was inactive ("incurably sick," lol), participated in a battle that gained ThunderClan Sunningrocks, began an intense rivalry with Reedstar that made the Gatherings and battles 150% more interesting, was the real leader that led the conquest against ShadowClan. Also, she was fairly old too because she was a senior warrior when she was picked as deputy and then made it about two years as leader.