Should Firestar Die?

There is alot of controversy if Firestar will die. He has lost 6 lives total, leaving him with only 3. (Dont believe me? Look it up). In Cats Of The Clans, Rock hinted that Firestar would lose all 9 lives. In Fading Echoes, Jayfeather sees Firestars lost lives in StarClan, and the cats talk about that they cannot speak until he loses his last life. Well, what would happen if he did? Brambleclaw would be leader (Nothing against Brambleclaw, but BrambleSTAR? Thats unheard of). It would be exciting, but if you think about it, The New Prophecy was kinda boring, Power Of Three was ok, and Omen Of The Stars was good, but the original warriors series was BOMB. And it was all about Rusty/Firepaw/Fireheart/Firestar. Then most of the characters became minor or they died. As I stated in a poll about fav characters. Well, personally I dont want Firestar to die, but it would make the series really dramatic. So if he did die?

Tell me:
How you would want him to die?
When would you want him to die?

I would want him to diein a great battle, involving all the clans versus a force like BloodClan, in the second to last book.

i am a scourage fan all the way throgh but threre r rumors about dark forest vs starclan i dont want firestar to die he is my fav chartor alive i think that he has to die in the 2nd or 3rd book in order for starclan to win

noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he can"t!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!he
I FRIKEN AWESOME BESIDES WHAT WOULD SANDSTORM DO WITHOUT HIM THEN AGAIN HE WILL HAVE SPOTTED LEAF IN STARCLAN...but still nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Yes he should die but in the battle between starclan and darkforest, Tigerstar should use the moved that Scourge did on him and BRUTALY kill Firestar. And then he will kill Princess!

Raggedkit, this topic is dead. Its been over a month since the last person posted.

Firestar has to die. He's too old, and he's been there for way too long. I actually want him to lose his final life in a way that isn't that spectacular, like illness, or maybe another bout of Greencough like the one he lost one of his other lives in. I think he should die because he puts his clanmates lives before himself, like how he's always all, "I don't need the herbs, give them to the other cats, " and then he loses a life. : P

:) BRAMBLESTAR! BRAMBLESTAR! BRAMBLESTAR! :)

Guys,this topic is dead. Stop posting please. ^^'

Deffinetley no, I love Firestar, he is the best cat in my opinion. My favorite series was deffinetley the New Prophecy, how was it boring? Discovering that Midnight wasn't a time of day, but a badger for starclan's sake! And Firestar's Quest was awesome, I read it twice and I still just love it. So, I would never like him to do.

But, if he did I would want him to have a more peaceful death, for all the hard work he has given ThunderClan. A death I would like for him would be getting a sickness... but not knowing it, so when it's his time to go, he leaves in his sleep and flys up to StarClan, but of course saying good-bye to his family.

- Mistykit

Do you listen? I said to stop posting here!

Jaybird wrote:

Do you listen? I said to stop posting here!

Gosh, sor-ry I didn't read your post, who knew you couldn't post on a thread on this website without
being yelled at...

Well I did say it about three times...

Er,Sorry for being snappy ^^'

i hope that Firestar doesnt die he's one of my favorite cats

Omfg.... Topic locked.